[정치] CNN: 北의 상습적 덫 앞에서 갈팡질팡하는 트럼프


 

트럼프: “상황, 곪아터지게 내버려 둘 순 없다

 

원문 2018.3.7.

 입력 2018.3.7.

 

[시사뷰타임즈] 대통령 도널드 트럼프는 빈번히 자기에게 악몽 같은 대북 각본은 남겨주었다고 전임 3명의 대통령들을 신랄하게 비난하는 바: 고립된 이 나라가 미국 본토를 직접적으로 곧 가격 할 수도 있다는 위협이 그것이다.

 

그러나 한국-북한 사이에 10년 만에 처음으로 열릴 정상회담에 앞서 해빙 분위기가 돌기 때문에, 트럼프는 자신의 전임자들과 똑같이 외교적으로 좌절하고, 허망하며 이러지도 저러지도 못하는 상황으로 곧 전락하게 될 수도 있다.

 

워싱튼과 서울을 갈라놓기 위해 북한 지도자 김정은이 교묘하게 전략적으로 나아가면서, 심각한 강대국들인 중국과 라셔(러시아)를 끌어들일 수도 있는 복잡한 전략적 춤을 추는데도 트럼프는 지켜보는 것외엔 달리 방도가 없닫.

 

가외로 그 어떤 것이라도 한다면 한국과 미국 동맹 관계를 -핵 위기를 해결함에 매우 중요할- 쪼개버릴 것이며 북한에 대한 지구촌의 압력에 균열이 생기게 하면서 미국을 끔찍한 전쟁 쪽으로 미끄러져 들어가게 할 수도 있다.

 

그러나 외교적인 작전을 공개하게 되면, 트럼프는 북한이 벼랑끝 전술을 전술을 펼치며 도발을 하고 그 이후론 지난 대통령들을 실족시켜 온 대화 제의 및 그동안의 것에 대한 양해를 이끌어 내려는 것이 따르게 된다.

 

트럼프는 이런 문제는 지금이 아니라, 과거 많은 행정부들이 야러 해에 걸쳐서 처리했어야 하는 것이다. 지금은 이런 문제를 처리할 적기가 아니다라고 말하면서 그러나 이게 우리가 다룰 수밖에 없는 카드들이다 우린 합당하게 처리하게 될 것이다라고 말한다.


Trump teeters on the edge of a familiar North Korean trap

 

Stephen Collinson Profile

Analysis by Stephen Collinson, CNN

Updated 0851 GMT (1651 HKT) March 7, 2018

 

Trump: Can't let North Korea situation fester

 

(CNN)President Donald Trump frequently scorches the last three presidents for leaving him a nightmare scenario on North Korea: the threat that the isolated state could soon deliver a nuclear weapon directly to the US mainland.

 

But as a thaw takes hold ahead of the first North Korea-South Korea summit in a decade, Trump could be about to be dragged down the same frustrating, illusory and inconclusive diplomatic path as his predecessors.

 

As North Korean leader Kim Jong Un skillfully maneuvers to split Washington and Seoul, and plays out an intricate strategic dance that could draw in crucial powers Russia and China, Trump has little option but to watch.

 

To do anything else would splinter the US-South Korean alliance -- which will be crucial to solving the nuclear crisis -- and could fracture global pressure on Pyongyang and put the US on a glide path toward a horrendous war.

 

But by allowing the diplomacy to unfold, Trump risks being played in the same old game of North Korean brinkmanship and provocations followed by offers of dialogue and trawls for concessions that have tripped up past presidents.

 

"This should have been handled over many years by many different administrations -- not now. This was not the right time to handle it," Trump said. "But these are the cards we were dealt. We're handling it properly."

 

History repeats?

 

The President is keenly aware of the challenge he faces, and the risk that he, for all his bluster and warnings that this time it will be different, could fall into a familiar trap.

 

"I think that their statement and the statements coming out of South Korea and North Korea have been very positive," Trump said Tuesday, after Pyongyang conveyed a message through the South that it was ready to talk about denuclearization, the key US demand.

     

Trump also said the sanctions his administration had put in place in conjunction with China had been "very, very strong and very biting," but offered an unusually hopeful assessment of the North Korean attitude.

 

"I think that they are sincere. ... I hope they're sincere. We're going to soon find out," he said.

 

Trump's circumspection contrasted with his inflammatory rhetoric threatening "fire and fury" over North Korea and demeaning putdowns of Kim as "Little Rocket Man," which put the world on edge last year.

    

Shifting gears

 

His approach Tuesday was nuanced and tempered, clearly calibrated to send messages to North and South Korea and China in particular. He welcomed the recent opening and apparent North Korean shifts, while registering appropriate skepticism, but was careful to avoid killing off all hope.

 

His rhetoric was also noticeably lacking in the brash triumphalism and grasping for credit that are a familiar part of his political style -- after all the White House could justifiably argue that its policy of imposing the most rigorous sanctions in history on North Korea, along with more buy-in from China than ever before, has directly led to the diplomatic breakthrough.

 

His critics hope that even Trump, no respecter of presidential convention or protocol, is starting to be sobered by the awful prospect of a war on the Korean Peninsula that could mean death for hundreds of thousands of civilians and thousands of US troops and would send a shock wave through the world's geopolitical system.

 

What does Trump want?

 

While the President was conciliatory, senior US officials worked behind the scenes to convey that there had been no moderation of the hardline US position.

 

A senior official told reporters that the US wants "credible moves" toward denuclearization from North Korea before agreeing to direct talks. The official also said that planned joint military exercises between the US and South Korea would go ahead.

 

The comment on the North's nuclear program was in effect a response to a message conveyed by Seoul's national security chief, Chung Eui-yong, after talks with Kim that Pyongyang was willing to talk to the US about giving up its nuclear weapons.

 

Top economic adviser Gary Cohn leaves White House in wake of tariff rift

 

Top economic adviser Gary Cohn leaves White House in wake of tariff rift

 

The White House strategy appears to be an attempt to give South Korean President Moon Jae-in space to work his initiative, But if he fails, US deference and encouragement at the outset could spare the Trump administration from being blamed, and so preserve the loose international coalition against the North.

 

Skepticism in DC

 

It's no surprise that skepticism is high in Washington over the offer. After all, the North agreed in 1994 and 2005 to give up its nuclear arsenal and cheated on the agreement both times.

 

"Maybe this is a breakthrough. I seriously doubt it," Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats said. "But like I said, hope springs eternal."

Robert Gallucci, who negotiated President Bill Clinton's 1994 Agreed Framework deal with North Korea, warned that Pyongyang's word had proved to be worth little in the past.

 

"We made a deal with the North and they gave up the program. They then pursued secretly a program using highly enriched uranium with the Pakistanis," he told CNN.

 

Christopher Hill, a former US North Korea negotiator who also served as ambassador to Seoul, was also loath to proclaim a breakthrough but said the opening was worth pursuing.

 

"I never combine optimism and North Korea in the same thought," Hill told CNN International's Robyn Curnow on Tuesday. "I think we also need to avoid ... irrational exuberance but I think we also need to avoid sounding negative and churlish about it."

 

Pessimism in Washington is rooted in suspicions that the North is simply playing for time, may be seeking some relief from sanctions without offering real concessions and is maneuvering to weaken Chinese resolve.

 

Its offer to halt nuclear and missile tests during the talks could simply signal that its program has advanced to such a stage that no current testing flights are necessary or planned. US experts are also waiting to see whether Pyongyang proposes steps that Washington has already ruled out, such as withdrawing US troops from the Korean Peninsula.

 

Empty seats at US table

 

The accelerating pace of the diplomacy between North and South Korea also risks catching Washington off-guard because it hardly has a crack team of negotiators steeped in Pyongyang's strategy at the ready.

 

The administration has failed to appoint an ambassador to one of its most crucial posts -- the embassy in Seoul -- despite being in office for over a year.

 

One candidate for the post, Victor Cha, was told by the White House that he didn't make the cut. In a subsequent Washington Post opinion piece, he expressed opposition to a reported White House study on the feasibility of a limited US military strike on North Korea.

 

Last week, the administration's North Korea negotiator, Joseph Yun, announced his retirement. The bench is thin in an administration that has often seemed to spurn the intricacies of diplomacy. The staffing shortages dampen any talk that shrewd US diplomatic strategy brought about the Korean thaw, though Secretary of State Rex Tillerson has tried to keep the door for dialogue open, despite being told last year by Trump that he was wasting his time.

 

As Trump risks falling into a familiar pattern when it comes to US presidents and North Korea, he is also going to come up against an equation that has confronted his predecessors, who concluded that the consequences of a war on the Korean Peninsula would be so horrific that even imperfect diplomacy turns into a default position."Dialogue is a good thing and any way to defuse tensions or miscommunication or miscalculation by the US or South Korea or North Korea are good things," Jung H. Pak a former CIA analyst who's now at the Brookings Institution, said on CNN's "Amanpour."

 

"But I think we are all clear that we want to go into this with wide eyes."


[기사/사진: CNN]



Comment



[ 社說 ]

경제두뇌 김광두의… 입력 2018.12.06. [시사뷰타임즈] ‘문재인 호’라 불리는 배에 커다란 구멍이 ... 더보기

[스페셜 NEWS]

“NASA 화성 생명체 감추고 있다“: 붉은 행성 폭발에서 일어나고 있는 일들 길이 2000KM의 연기기둥 © ESA - European Space Agency 웜문 2018.10.24 입력 2018.10.24. [시사뷰타임즈] ... 더보기

[포토 NEWS]

양주 향교(鄕校)는 살아있다...현대에 맞는 교육 중 sisaview DB 입력 2018.11.19. [시사뷰타임즈] 경기도 양주시에는 양주 향교가 있다. 1983년 9월 19... 더보기

[정확한 정보] Q&A

-‘피폭선량’ 이란게 뭔가? Image source 입력 2018.5.25 [시사뷰타임즈] ‘피폭’이라는 말은 우선 떠오르는 것이 투하한 폭... 더보기

[종합 NEWS]

조국, 야당의 사퇴요구 이전에 진짜 사퇴깜이었다 사진출처 = MediaVOP 조국, 스스로 사퇴하는 척이라도 해야 옳았다 입력 2018.12.05. [시사뷰타임... 더보기

[ 시·선·집·중 ]

“북측, 협조적이었다” 우리측 철도 공동조사반의 이해 안가는 말. 사진=경기관광공사 입력 2018.12.05. [시사뷰타임즈] 지난달 30일, 도라산 역에서 출발하여 북... 더보기

[ TOP ISSUE ]

강화된 개정 ‘윤창호’법: 음주운전 처벌에 최고 무기징역까지 엄벌 그림출처 = newsX 입력 2018.12.07. [시사뷰타임즈] 7일인 오늘, 국회 본회의에서 음주운전의 처... 더보기

[오피니언 NEWS]

죽을 때까지 일하는 한국인들: 그들의 삶을 되 찾을 수 있을까. 채수홍과 박혜숙의 행복했던 한 때 원문 2018.11.5. [시사뷰타임즈] 박혜숙 -과로사로 남편을 ... 더보기

[제휴 및 광고 문의]

제휴및 광고문의 게시판입니다. 시사뷰 타임즈는 시사뷰 까페와 연계된 것으로서 적지 않은 조회가 있습니다. 따라서 시사... 더보기

[기사제보 받습니다]

이 게시판은 회원가입후 작성 가능하며, 역사물 또는 어떠한 기록물 등은 … 기사 제보도 아닌데 장난삼아 한 두줄 글을 올리는 사람도 있고 그 중에는 악성코드가 들... 더보기

[타임스퀘어]

제18대 대선 투표지 등 폐기 중단 요청 @제18대 대선 선거무효 소송인단 제18대 대선 투표지 등 폐기 중단 요청 * 날짜 - 2017. 8. 11.*... 더보기

[메인 큰 타이틀]

文 적폐청산? 의원연맹, 해외 돌아다니며 세금으로 펑펑 써...현 정권부터 … 입력 2018.12.05. [시사뷰타임즈] 국회 의원연맹이라는 곳이 국회 활동과 연관성도 없는 일로 ... 더보기

[메인 작은 타이틀]

미국에 너무 밀린 한미FTA 개정안 국회 비준이라니 개정원안 서명 당시의 모습 Image copyrightEPA 입력 2018.12.07. [시사뷰타임즈] 한미FTA 개정협상... 더보기